Series 1913 – 2025

Money from thin air

You earn it by the hour. Others create it with a keystroke. Scroll to see what that does to your savings, your wages, your home and almost everything you buy.

Since 1913 the dollar has lost 97% of what it could buy.

$0 Borrowed by the US government since you opened this page, at its 2025 pace of roughly $1.8 trillion a year.
Scroll

Chapter I

Money is your time, stored

You trade hours of your life for money. A week of work becomes a number in an account. Money has one job that matters more than any other: to carry those hours safely into the future, so you can spend them later on a home, on your children, on a rest.

Now picture someone who can create money without working any hours at all. Every unit they create is a claim on the same goods and the same labour as yours. They added nothing to the world. They added a claim, and yours got smaller.

That power exists. It is legal, it is routine, and it is used every single day.

Chapter II

The oldest trick in government

Roman emperors had bills to pay: armies, games, monuments. Raising taxes caused riots. So they found a quieter way.

They collected the silver coins, melted them down, mixed in cheap copper, and stamped out more coins than they had taken in. Each coin still said one denarius. Each held a little less silver.

Keep scrolling and watch three centuries pass.

DENARIVS X

27 BC

Augustus

97%silver

A day's pay for a soldier. Nearly pure.

Soldiers demanded more coins for the same service. Merchants raised prices. Savings held in coin became worthless. By the time the silver was gone, so was the trust that held the empire's trade together.

Rome's rulers needed furnaces and copper to do this. Ours need neither.

Chapter III

Your bank does not have your money

Most of us picture a bank as a warehouse. You put money in, the bank keeps it safe. That picture is wrong.

When you deposit $1,000, the bank keeps a sliver and lends out the rest. The borrower spends it, and it lands in someone else's account. You still have your $1,000. So do they. Then the bank lends that out too.

Real cash in the vault$1,000
Money in people's accounts$1,000
Created from nothing$0

    Textbook model: the bank keeps 10% of each deposit and lends the other 90%.

    That is the polite, textbook version. The reality is looser. Banks don't wait for a deposit before they lend. They type the loan into existence.

    “Whenever a bank makes a loan, it simultaneously creates a matching deposit in the borrower's bank account, thereby creating new money.”

    Bank of England, Quarterly Bulletin, 2014

    The same paper says about 97% of the money in circulation in Britain exists only as these bank deposits. And in March 2020 the US Federal Reserve cut the cash banks must hold against deposits to zero.

    Print banknotes in your garage and you go to prison. A bank does the digital equivalent and charges you interest on it.

    Chapter IV

    Heads they win. Tails you pay.

    A system like this is fragile. The bank has promised the same money to many people at once. If enough of them ask for it on the same day, it isn't there. For centuries the fear of that day kept bankers careful.

    Then central banks were given the job of stopping the panic. When a bank runs short, the central bank lends it freshly created money. That brought calm. It also removed the one thing that punished recklessness.

    When the bets pay off

    The bank keeps the profit

    Bonuses, dividends and share buybacks. The gains are private.

    When the bets fail

    You cover the loss

    Rescue money is created from nothing. Everyone who holds the currency pays through its falling value.

    In 2008 the banks at the centre of the crisis were rescued with trillions in new money and guarantees. Executives kept their bonuses. Millions of families lost their homes.

    Economists call this moral hazard. A gambler who keeps his winnings and hands on his losses will keep raising the stakes.

    Chapter V

    A credit card with no limit

    Governments have the emperor's problem. Voters like spending and dislike taxes. So governments spend more than they collect and borrow the difference. Washington has done this in all but four years since 1970.

    A borrower who never stops usually runs out of lenders. Unless one lender can never run out. Since 2008, central banks have bought government debt by the trillion and paid for it with money that did not exist the moment before. The official name is quantitative easing.

    Money created by the US Federal Reserve, in trillions of dollars

    Federal Reserve total assets at year end, 2003 to 2024, rounded. Source: Federal Reserve H.4.1 (FRED series WALCL).
    US national debt, 1971$0.4TThe year the dollar's last link to gold was cut.
    US national debt, today$36T+Roughly ninety times larger.
    Dollars in existence, 2020 to 2022+40%Two years. The broad money supply, M2.

    Chapter VI

    More money. Same stuff.

    Creating money does not create bread, houses or hours in the day. It only creates more claims on the bread, houses and hours that already exist.

    Here is a village with ten loaves and ten coins. You have saved five of those coins. Now run the printer.

    Bread in the village

    Coins in the village

    Price of a loaf1.0coins
    Your five saved coins buy5.0loaves

    Nobody baked less. Nobody got greedy. Bread did not become scarce. Money became plentiful, so each coin commands less.

    Not every price rise starts at the printer. A drought or a war can make things dearer for a while. But a rise in almost all prices, year after year for generations, needs a money supply that never stops growing.

    We are told prices are rising. Look again. Your money is falling.

    Chapter VII

    The plan is for you to lose

    None of this is hidden. Central banks publish a target: your money should lose 2% of its value every year. At that pace half of it is gone in 35 years, the length of a working life.

    In 2022 prices in the US rose 9% in twelve months. Try the numbers on your own savings.

    $10,000 put aside today will buy what this buys now $4,120 59% of your stored work, gone.

    Each square is 1% of your savings' buying power. Cash only, before interest. Savings accounts have paid less than inflation for most of the past fifteen years.

    Chapter VIII

    Who gets the new money first?

    New money does not fall evenly from the sky. It enters the economy at particular doors and reaches people in a particular order.

    A banker named Richard Cantillon described this almost 300 years ago. Those who receive new money first spend it at yesterday's prices. By the time it reaches the last in line, prices have already risen. What the first gain, the last lose.

    What a newly created dollar still buys by the time it reaches you

    1. Banks and governments

      They create it or borrow it first, and spend it at the old prices.

    2. Big investors and borrowers

      Cheap credit arrives early. They buy shares, property and companies.

    3. Owners of assets

      Their shares and houses rise in price before anything else does.

    4. People paid a wage

      A pay rise comes eventually, after the rent and the groceries went up.

    5. Savers and pensioners

      The new money never reaches them. The higher prices do.

    An illustration of the order of events, not measured data.

    It is a transfer from the last in line to the first. Nobody voted for it.

    Chapter IX

    Assets soar. Wages crawl.

    New money flows first into the things early receivers buy: shares, bonds, property. Those prices climb fastest. If you already own assets, you feel rich. If you sell your hours for a wage, you watch the ladder being pulled up.

    Since the money printing began in earnest: 2009 = 100

    S&P 500 index and average hourly earnings of US private-sector workers, year end, 2009 to 2024. Not adjusted for inflation. Sources: S&P Dow Jones Indices; Bureau of Labor Statistics.
    Share of all US stocks owned by the richest 10%~90%The bottom half of households own about 1%.
    A typical new home, 1971<3 yrsof a typical household's income.
    A typical new home, today5+ yrsof a typical household's income.

    Cheap money is not the only reason shares and houses rose. It is the reason they rose so much faster than pay. Young people today are no lazier than their grandparents. They are paid in a currency that leaks, and asked to buy assets that have been inflated with it.

    Chapter X

    What it does to people

    Money touches every decision a person makes about the future. Break the money and you bend all of those decisions.

    Chapter XI

    Why everything keeps getting worse

    When a business sees its costs rise every year, it has two choices. Charge you more, or give you less. Customers notice a higher price. They rarely notice a smaller bar.

    Price on the shelf$2.00
    What you get100 g

    Same wrapper. Same price. Keep scrolling.

    Smaller packets. Thinner fabric. Chipboard where there was timber. Appliances that last seven years where they used to last twenty-five. A chatbot where there was a person. Each cut is small. Together they mean the price held still while the thing itself decayed, and official inflation figures barely register it.

    Cheap money rots the other end of business too. When borrowing costs almost nothing, a company doesn't need to earn its keep by serving customers well. It can lose money for a decade to capture a market, then squeeze the people trapped inside. It can borrow to buy its own shares where it once built better products. Firms that should have closed stay alive on cheap loans.

    There is a crude word for the result: enshittification.

    When money can't hold its value, nothing gets built to hold its value.

    Chapter XII

    Inflation is a cancer

    The comparison is exact enough to be uncomfortable.

    1. It starts small

      Two per cent a year. Nothing you would see a doctor about.

    2. It feeds on healthy tissue

      It grows by consuming savings, wages and the trust between people who trade with each other.

    3. The body reorganises around it

      Banks, governments, borrowers and markets all come to depend on the next dose of new money. Stopping would hurt, so nobody stops.

    4. Each treatment is a larger dose of the cause

      The crash of 2001 was treated with cheap money. That fed the crash of 2008, which was treated with trillions. 2020 was treated with trillions more.

    5. Left alone, it kills the host

      Germany in 1923. Zimbabwe in 2008. Venezuela in 2018. These were not different diseases. They were the same one, further along.

    “There is no subtler, no surer means of overturning the existing basis of society than to debauch the currency. The process engages all the hidden forces of economic law on the side of destruction, and does it in a manner which not one man in a million is able to diagnose.”

    Chapter XIII

    No villains required

    None of this needs a conspiracy. Bankers lend because lending pays. Politicians spend because spending wins votes. Central bankers print because the alternative is a crash on their watch. Each is responding sensibly to the rules.

    The rules are the problem. A small number of institutions may create money from nothing, and are rescued when it goes wrong. Everything in this story follows from that one privilege.

    Fair questions deserve straight answers.

    Isn't a little inflation good for the economy?

    That is the mainstream view: gentle inflation encourages spending and makes debts easier to carry. Look at who is encouraged and who is eased. Borrowers and asset owners gain; savers and wage earners pay. Prices can also fall while living standards rise. Televisions and computers have done it for decades, and in the late 1800s US prices drifted down while the economy grew quickly. Falling prices are how progress is supposed to reach everyone.

    Don't wages go up with prices?

    Eventually, partly, and unevenly. Wages are among the last prices to move, which is exactly the effect Cantillon described. The delay is the loss, and it lands hardest on people with the least bargaining power.

    Don't we need banks to lend?

    Yes. Lending real savings to people with good ideas is one of the most useful things finance does. The objection is narrower: lending money that was created on the spot, with the losses covered by the public. The first is investment. The second is dilution.

    Is money printing really behind everything?

    No. Technology, trade, tax and planning rules all matter. The claim here is that broken money sits underneath those forces and makes each of them worse, and that it is the cause we discuss the least.

    Wasn't the gold standard a disaster?

    It had real problems, including regular banking panics. Many of those panics came from the same lending of money that wasn't there. The principle matters more than the metal: money that nobody can create at will.

    The alternative

    Sound money is a simple idea

    Nobody gets to create it from nothing. No bank, no government, no emperor. To get it, you have to give something of value in return. For most of history that was the ordinary meaning of the word money.

    The next time you hear about a stimulus, a bailout or a rescue package, ask three questions.

    Who created this money?Who gets it first?Who pays?

    Once you see it, you will see it everywhere.

    Figures are for the United States unless stated, and are rounded. The village, the chocolate bar and the order-of-arrival diagram are illustrations.

    1913 A 1913 dollar buys 100¢